Evaluation of the Perceived Effectiveness of Online Protection Policy for Minors Compound Research Evidence from the Dual Perspectives of Minors and Parents

Abstract

Abstract:

The study evaluates the effectiveness of online protection policy for minors and providesevidence-based insights for formulating and implementing relevant policies. A mixed-methods approachwas adopted incorporating semi-structured interviews coding analysis and questionnaires. It carried outa compound study on the perceived effectiveness of online protection policy for minors from the dualperspectives of minors and parents. The implementation effect of online protection policy for minors isgood but there are still problems such as insufficient policy publicity and large differences in theeffectiveness of online protection policy for minors in urban and rural areas. Four dimensions of perceivedeffectiveness were identified clarity comprehensiveness relevance and feasibility. The policy receivedhigh ratings for clarity comphre-hensiveness and relevance but lower ratings for feasibility. Byanalyzing the dual perspectives of minors and parents this study comprehensively explores the evaluationof the perceived effectiveness and proposes targeted recommendations for the optimization of policy andgovernance for minors online protection.

Wang Ping1 2 Su Hang1 Li Shuyang3（1 School of Information Management Zhengzhou University 2 Henan Provincial Culture and TourismPublic Service Innovation Research Base 3 Shanghai Library）. Evaluation of the Perceived Effectiveness of Online Protection Policy for Minors Compound Research Evidence from the Dual Perspectives of Minors and Parents[J]. Libraly Journal, 2025, 44(414): 84-90.

References

[ 1 ] CNNIC. 第53 次中国互联网络发展状况统计报告[ EB / OL ]. [ 2024-04-29 ]. https / / www.cnnic. net. cn / n4 / 2024 / 0322 / c88-10964. html.

[ 2 ] 钱大军,薛爱昌. 繁华与无序:法律体系建构的中国模式之检讨[J]. 法律科学(西北政法大学学报),2016, 34(1):16 27.

[ 3 ] 国家互联网信息办公室. 国家互联网信息办公室发布《儿童个人信息网络保护规定》[EB / OL].

[ 2024-04-10 ]. https / / www. gov. cn / xinwen /2019-08 / 23 / content_5423865. htm.

[ 4 ] 何波. 论中国未成年人网络保护法律制度体系的改进[J]. 法律科学(西北政法大学学报),2024,42(2):94 109.

[ 5 ] 林维. 专家解读|林维:迈向中国式现代化的未成年人网络保护[ EB / OL ] . [ 2024 01 22 ].http / / www. cac. gov. cn / 2023-10 / 25 / c _16998906 53370857. htm.

[ 6 ] 国家互联网信息办公室. 《移动互联网未成年人模式建设指南》[ EB / OL ]. [ 2024-11-15 ].https / / www. cac. gov. cn / 2024-11 / 15 / c _17333643047492 88. htm.

[ 7 ] 人民日报. 高举中国特色社会主义伟大旗帜为全面建设社会主义现代化国家而团结奋斗———习近平同志代表第十九届中央委员会向大会作的报告摘登[EB / OL]. [2024-08-31]. http / /www. qstheory. cn / yaowen / 2022-10 / 17 / c _ 1129067786. htm.

[ 8 ] 周南平,崔祥民,葛恒刚. 复杂心理下的诉求与引导:“双减”政策家长感知研究[J]. 中国教育学刊,2023(8):24 29.

[ 9 ] 廖嘉琦. 网络平台儿童个人信息保护政策分析———基于《儿童个人信息网络保护规定》的框架[J]. 图书馆建设,2021(2):98 107.

[10] 李青,苏明雪,聂含韵. 教育类App 隐私保护评价指标构建和保护现状研究[J]. 中国远程教育,2022(9):69 77.

[11] 方增泉,秦月,张恒. 网络游戏平台未成年人保护指标分析[J]. 少年儿童研究,2023(3):11 18.

[12] Chowdhury W. Toys that talk to strangers a look atthe privacy policies of connected toys C / /Proceedings of the Future Technologies Conference.Vancourver Springer cham 2018 152 158. [13] 白净,赵莲. 中美儿童网络隐私保护研究[J]. 新闻界,2014(4):56 62.

[14] Bulger M Burton P O??Neill B et al. Wherepolicy and practice collide comparing UnitedStates South African and European Unionapproaches to protecting children online J . NewMedia & Society 19 5 750 764.

[15] 韩悦,胥兴春. 未成年人保护视域下网络游戏监管政策的演进与前瞻———基于2000 ~ 2020 年政策文本的分析[J]. 上海教育科研,2021 (12): 16 22.

[16] Gilad M Fishbein D H Nave G et al. Sciencefor policy to protect children in cyberspace J .Science 2023 379 6639 1294 1297.

[17] 周晓红. 公共管理学概论[M]. 北京:中央广播电视大学出版社,2016:71.

[18] 芮国强,彭伟,陈童. 地方政府人才政策效能评估———以常州为例的实证研究[ J ]. 学海, 2017(6):156 160.

[19] 郭鹏飞,周英男. 基于扎根理论的中国城市绿色转型政策评价指标提取及建构研究[J]. 管理评论,2018, 30(8):257 267.

[20] 国务院未成年人网络保护条例[EB / OL]. [2024-05-23]. https / / www. gov. cn / zhengce / content /202310/ content_6911288. htm.

[21] 康亚通. 青少年网络沉迷研究综述[J]. 中国青年社会科学,2019, 38(6):130 135.