Open Data Ecosystem: A Systemic Literature Review

Abstract

Abstract:

The studies on the open data ecosystem have theoretical and practical implications for thedata market and digital economy. This study is to review the status quo in the research on open dataecosystems and identify the directions of future studies by finding the weak sides of existing literature.The research methods are systematic literature reviews. The investigated literature databases includeSemantic Scholar, ACM Digital Library, IOS Press Content Library, Sage Journals, Wiley Online Library,Taylor & Francis Online, ScienceDirect, Oxford Academic, Emerald, ProQuest, and CNKI. After asystematic review, this study extracts a topical framework for the research on the open data ecosystem andthen discusses the status quo of each topic. The research domain of open data ecosystems is a tributaryof the research on the open data, which is still in the middle of development and needs the attention ofresearchers, especially regarding models, elements, and effectiveness assessment of open data ecosystems.Furthermore, the governance structure, operational mechanism, the nurturing and evolution of the opendata ecosystem could become the topics of future studies.

Ma Haiqun, Wang Bengang ( Research Center of Information Resources Management, Heilongjiang University, Library of Dali University ). Open Data Ecosystem: A Systemic Literature Review[J]. Libraly Journal, 2022, 41(11): 8-18.

References

[ 1 ] Open Government Data [EB/OL]. [2022-04-18].https://www.oecd.org/gov/digital-government/open-government-data.htm.

[ 2 ] Open， Public， Electronic， and NecessaryGovernment Data Act [EB/OL]. [2022-04-18].https://www.datacoalition.org/policy-issues/opendata/open-government-data-act/.

[ 3 ] Bonina C， Eaton B. Cultivating open governmentdata platform ecosystems through governance：Lessons from Buenos Aires， Mexico Cityand Montevideo [J]. Government InformationQuarterly， 2020， 37（3）： 101479.

[ 4 ] Davies T. Open Data： Infrastructures andecosystems [C]//Proceedings of Web ScienceConference. 2011：1–6.

[ 5 ] 张贵，温科，宋新平，等. 创新生态系统：理论与实践[M]. 北京：经济管理出版社，2018：5–6.

[ 6 ] 梅亮，陈劲，刘洋. 创新生态系统：源起、知识演进和理论框架[J]. 科学学研究， 2014， 32（12）：1771–1780.

[ 7 ] Adner R. Ecosystem as structure：An actionableconstruct for strategy[J]. Journal of Management，2017， 43（1）： 39–58.

[ 8 ] 陈衍泰. 创新管理：从创新网络、创新系统到创新生态系统的演化[J]. 研究与发展管理， 2018，30（4）：1.

[ 9 ] 曾国屏，苟尤钊，刘磊. 从“创新系统”到“创新生态系统”[J]. 科学学研究， 2013， 31（1）：4–12.

[10] 陈劲，李飞. 基于生态系统理论的我国国家技术创新体系构建与评估分析[J]. 自然辩证法通讯，2011， 33（1）： 61–66；123–124；127.

[11] 陈剑，刘运辉. 数智化使能运营管理变革：从供应链到供应链生态系统[J]. 管理世界，2021，37（11）：227–240 ；14.

[12] 杨蕙馨，宁萍.平台边界选择与平台生态治理[J].社会科学辑刊，2021（5）：135–144.

[13] Ding L， Lebo T， Erickson J S， et al. TWCLOGD： A portal for linked open government dataecosystems [J]. Journal of Web Semantics， 2011，9（3）： 325–333.

[14] 王本刚，马海群. 开放政府理论分析框架：概念、政策与治理[J]. 情报资料工作，2015（6）：35–39.

[15] Matheus R， Janssen M. A systematic literaturestudy to unravel transparency enabled by opengovernment data： The window theory [J]. PublicPerformance & Management Review， 2020， 43（3）：503–534.

[16] Park S， Gil-Garcia J R. Open data innovation：Visualizations and process redesign as a way tobridge the transparency-accountability gap [J].Government Information Quarterly， 2022，39（1）：101456.

[17] McBride K， Aavik G， Toots M， et al. How doesopen government data driven co-creation occur?Six factors and a‘ perfect storm’； insights fromChicago’s food inspection forecasting model [J].Government Information Quarterly， 2019， 36（1）：88–97.

[18] Attard J， Orlandi F， Scerri S， et al. A systematicreview of open government data initiatives [J].Government Information Quarterly， 2015， 32（4）：399–418.

[19] Janssen K. The influence of the PSI directive onopen government data： An overview of recentdevelopments [J]. Government InformationQuarterly， 2011， 28（4）： 446–456.

[20] J u ana -Es p inos a S， Luj án-Mor a S. Op engovernment data portals in the European Union：Considerations， development， and expectations [J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change，2019， 149： 119769.

[21] Lee J， Ham J， Choi B. Effect of governmentdata openness on a knowledge-based economy[J].Procedia Computer Science， 2016， 91： 158–167.

[22] Stahl O G. Open government in the United States [J].The Indian Journal of Public Administration，1979， 25： 1128–1139.

[23] Liu Z G， Li X Y， Zhu X H. Scenario modeling forgovernment big data governance decision-making：Chinese experience with public safety services [J].Information & Management， 2022， 59（3）：103622.

[24] Ahn M J， Chen Y C. Digital transformationtoward AI-augmented public administration：The perception of government employees andthe willingness to use AI in government [J].Government Information Quarterly， 2022，39（2）： 101664.

[25] Lima M S M， Delen D. Predicting and explainingcorruption across countries： A machine learningapproach [J]. Government Information Quarterly，2020， 37（1）： 101407.

[26] 关于坚持和完善中国特色社会主义制度推进国家治理体系和治理能力现代化若干重大问题的决定[EB/OL]. [2022-03-31]. http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2019-11/05/content_5449023.htm.

[27] 关于构建更加完善的要素市场化配置体制机制的意见[EB/OL]. [2022-04-18]. http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2020-04/09/content_5500622.htm.

[28] Zuiderwijk A， Janssen M， Kaa G， et al. Thewicked problem of commercial value creationin open data ecosystems： Policy guidelines forgovernments [J]. Information Polity， 2016，21（3）： 223–236.

[29] Harrison T M， Pardo T A， Cook M. Creatingopen government ecosystems： A research anddevelopment agenda [J]. Future Internet，2012，4（4）： 900–928.

[30] Heimst?dt M， Saunderson F， Heath T. Fromtoddler to teen： Growth of an open data ecosystem-A longitudinal analysis of open data developmentsin the UK [J]. JeDEM： eJournal of eDemocracyand Open Government，2014： 123–135.

[31] Oliveira M L S， Lima G F B， Lóscio B F.Investigations into data ecosystems： a systematicmapping study [J]. Knowledge and InformationSystems， 2019， 61： 589–630.

[32] 杜运周，李佳馨，刘秋辰，等. 复杂动态视角下的组态理论与QCA 方法：研究进展与未来方向[J].管理世界， 2021，37（3）：12–13；180–197.

[33] 袁红，王焘. 政府开放数据生态系统可持续发展实现路径的系统动力学分析[J]. 图书情报工作，2021，65（17）：13–25.

[34] Moore J F. Predators and prey： A new ecology ofcompetition [J]. Harvard Business Review， 1993，71（3）： 75–86.

[35] Zuiderwijk A， Janssen M， Davis C. Innovationwith open data： Essential elements of opendata ecosystems [J]. Information Polity， 2014，19（1/2）： 17–33.

[36] Schalkwyk F， Willmers M， McNaughton M.Viscous Open Data： The roles of intermediariesin an open data ecosystem [J]. InformationTechnology for Development， 2016，22（sup1）：68–83.

[37] Gelhaar J， Otto B. Challenges in the emergenceof data ecosystems [C]//Twenty-Third Pacific AsiaConference on Information Systems（ PACIS）.Dubai， UAE， 2020： 1–14.

[38] Csaki C. Open data ecosystems： A comparison ofvisual models [C]//Electronic Government and theInformation Systems Perspective： 8th InternationalConference on Electronic Government and theInformation Systems Perspective （EGOVIS2019）， 26–29 August 2019， Linz， Austria， 2019：16–30.

[39] Oliveira M I S， Lóscio B F. What is a dataecosystem? [C]//Proceedings of the 19th AnnualInternational Conference on Digital GovernmentResearch： Governance in the Data Age. 2018： 1–9.

[40] Donge W， Bharosa N， Janssen M. Data-drivengovernment： Cross-case comparison of datastewardship in data ecosystems [J]. GovernmentInformation Quarterly， 2021： 101642.

[41] Styrin E， Luna-Reyes L F， Harrison T M. Opendata ecosystems： an international comparison [J].Transforming Government： People， Process andPolicy， 2017， 11（ 1）： 132–156.

[42] Runeson P， Olsson T， Lin?ker J. Open dataecosystems-An empirical investigation into anemerging industry collaboration concept [J].Journal of Systems and Software， 2021， 182：111088.

[43] Gelhaar J， Gro? T， Otto B. A taxonomy for dataecosystems [C]//Proceedings of the 54th HawaiiInternational Conference on System Sciences（HICSS）. 2021：6113–6122.

[44] Dawes S S， Vidiasova L， Parkhimovich O.Planning and designing open government dataprograms： An ecosystem approach [J]. GovernmentInformation Quarterly， 2016， 33（1）： 15–27.

[45] Ruijer E， Dingelstad J， Meijer A. Studyingcomplex systems through design interventionsprobing open government data ecosystems in theNetherlands [J]. Public Management Review，2021： 1–21.

[46] Donker F W， Loenen B. How to assess the successof the open data ecosystem? [J]. InternationalJournal of Digital Earth， 2017， 10（3）： 284–306.

[47] McBride K， Olesk M， Kütt A， et al. Systemicchange， open data ecosystem performanceimprovements， and empirical insights fromEstonia： A country-level action research study[J].Information Polity，2020， 25（ 3）： 377–402.

[48] 郑娜静. 我国政府开放数据生态系统评价指标构建研究[D]. 石家庄：河北大学，2021.

[49] Lee D. Building an open data ecosystem： an Irishexperience [C]//Proceedings of the 8th InternationalConference on Theory and Practice of ElectronicGovernance.2014： 351–360.

[50] 田王超. 协同治理视域下数据开放生态系统构建研究[D]. 大连：辽宁师范大学，2020.

[51] Gupta A， Panagiotopoulos P， Bowen F. Anorchestration approach to smart city data ecosystems [J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change，2020， 153： 119929.

[52] Turki S， Martin S， Renault S. How open dataecosystems are stimulated? [C]//Proceedings of theInternational Conference on Electronic Governance andOpen Society： Challenges in Eurasia（eGose ’17）.Association for Computing Machinery， New York，NY， USA，2017： 179–187.

[53] Lin?ker J， Runeson P. Public sector platformsgoing open： Creating and growing an ecosystemwith open collaborative development [C]//Proceedings of the 16th International Symposiumon Open Collaboration （OpenSym 2020）.Association for Computing Machinery， New York，NY， USA， Article 10， 2020： 1–10.

[54] 史园园. 开放政府数据的生态系统研究[D]. 南昌：南昌航空大学，2018.

[55] 王颖. 数据开放生态系统视角下广东省级政府数据开放研究[D]. 广州：暨南大学，2019.

[56] 门理想，王丛虎.中国地方政府数据开放建设成效的影响因素探究——基于生态系统理论框架[J].现代情报，2021，41（2）：152–161.

[57] 郑磊. 开放政府数据的价值创造机理：生态系统的视角[J]. 电子政务，2015（7）：2–7.

[58] Lin?ker J， Runeson P. Collaboration in opengovernment data ecosystems： Open cross-sectorsharing and co-development of data and software [C]//Electronic Government： 19th IFIP WG 8.5international conference on electronic government（EGOV 2020）， 31 August-2 September 2020.Linkoping， Sweden，2020： 290–303.

[59] Yoon A， Copeland A. Toward community-inclusivedata ecosystems： Challenges and opportunities ofopen data for community-based organizations [J].Journal of the Association for Information Scienceand Technology， 2020， 71：1439–1454.

[60] Reggi L. Open government data strategies andgovernance networks inclusiveness： Lessons abouttransparency， use， and the creation of ecosystems [D].New York ：The University at Albany， StateUniversity of New York， 2020.

[61] Misra D， Mishra A， Babbar S， et al. Opengovernment data policy and indian ecosystems [C]//Proceedings of the 10th International Conferenceon Theory and Practice of Electronic Governance（ICEGOV ’17）. Association for ComputingMachinery， New York， USA，2017： 218–227.