图书馆杂志

图书馆杂志 ›› 2025, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (413): 138-148.

• 文献考论 • 上一篇    

两部书贾作伪的清齐召南校跋本《窦氏联珠集》

刘晓丽1, 2 (1 中国国家博物馆 2 山东大学中国经学研究中心)   

  • 出版日期:2025-09-15 发布日期:2025-09-29
  • 作者简介:

    刘晓丽 中国国家博物馆陈列工作部,馆员;山东大学中国经学研究中心研究员。中国古典文献学博士、博士后。研究方向: 目录版本校勘学、稿抄本研究。E-mail liuxiao126000@126. com 北京 100006

Two Falsified Versions of Doushi Lianzhu Ji Which Corrected Inscription and Postscript by Qi Zhaonan in the Qing Dynasty

Liu Xiaoli1 2 (1 National Museum of China 2 Center for Chinese Economic Studies Shandong University)   

  • Online:2025-09-15 Published:2025-09-29
  • About author:Liu Xiaoli1 2 (1 National Museum of China 2 Center for Chinese Economic Studies Shandong University)

摘要:

中国科学院图书馆藏清天台齐氏抄本及天津图书馆藏清齐召南校跋本《窦氏联珠集》皆为书贾作伪。此二本作伪所依据的版本是中国国家图书馆藏清许永镐抄本。书中叶眉及叶脚所谓齐召南的朱笔批校乃过录何焯、劳权校记;卷尾两则署名齐召南的跋文亦为书商抄录他人跋文,此二跋一为许永镐所作,一为劳权所作;书中《杏山馆听子规》一首,亦非齐召南所补,实为清嘉庆十五年(1810)黄丕烈据宋本补录;书中所钤齐召南、严元照的印章亦属书贾伪造。这两部“ 清齐召南校跋本”作伪的时间应该在清道光二十四年(1844) 五月之后,民国元年(1912) 七月之前;作伪之人可能是正文斋主人谭锡庆。

关键词: 作伪&emsp, 《窦氏联珠集》&emsp, 齐召南&emsp, 批校&emsp, 题跋

Abstract: The  transcripts of Doushi Lianzhu Ji transcribed by Qi Zhaonan in the Qing Dynasty collected by the Library of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the Tianjin Public Library respectively are all forgeries of the booksellers. As a corroborative edition for the forgery of these two transcripts is acopy of Xu Yonghao from the National Library of China. The so-called red handwriting of Qi Zhaonan inthe header and footer of the book is actually recorded by He Zhuo and Lao Quan. The two postscripts of Qi Zhaonan at the end of the volume were actually copied by the bookseller from Xu Yonghao and LaoQuan. The poetry nominated for Xin Shan Gua Ting Zi Gui in the transcripts was not supplemented by QiZhaonan but was recorded by Huang Pilie in the 15th year of the Jiaqing reign of the Qing Dynasty1810 based on the Song Dynastys edition. The seals of Qi Zhaonan and Yan Yuanzhao stamped in thetranscripts are also forged by booksellers. These two manuscripts might be forged after May of the 24thyear of the Qing Dynastys Daoguang reign 1844 and before July of the first year of the Republic ofChina 1912 . The perpetrator may be Tan Xiqing who is the owner of the Zhengwen Study.

Key words: Fake, Doushi Lianzhu Ji, Qi Zhaonan, Postil and collation, Preface and postscript