Abstract: The anthology of retrospective is an anthology edited by Wang Shizhen, Qianlong seventeen
years, Lu Jianzeng and his colleagues have been neat to unified order, add biography, engraving in Yangzhou.
According to an article of Wang Chang, Hui Dong and Shen Dacheng also participated in the editors of the
book, and was widely accepted. But if we taking into account the The anthology of retrospective published
time and Zhang Yuan’s activities, we believe that The anthology of retrospective has none matter with Hui
Dong, Shen Dacheng.Wang Chang may be affected by the works of Hui Dong, or mistakenly credited
Zhang Yuan’s poetry

Key words: The anthology of retrospective, Wang Chang, Hui Dong, Shen Dacheng