Libraly Journal

Libraly Journal ›› 2017, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (8): 107-112.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Discussion on Review of Erya Zheng Xuan Zhu Jicun By Xu Sen

Hu Tao   

  • Online:2017-08-15 Published:2017-11-13

Abstract:

There are some doubtful points in Peng Xishuang’s paper Review of Erya Zheng Xuan Zhu Jicun By Xu Sen which published in the Library Journal: the calculation of the number of Xu Sen’book was wrong; it was wrong to say that Xu Sen confused Zheng Xuan Ben Erya with Zheng Xuan Zhu Erya, Xu
Sen’s book was plagiarism and Xu’s analysis is meaningless. It was too subjectivity to affirm the material in Huilin Yinyi is not credible. The criticism of Erya Gulin Xulu was misconduct and misreading.

Key words:

Review of Erya Zheng Xuan Zhu Jicun By Xu Sen, Discussion, Compilation, Erya Gulin