图书馆杂志

图书馆杂志 ›› 2026, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (9): 126-133.

• 国际交流 • 上一篇    下一篇

威甘德反思美国图书馆职业的理论进路:一项基于福柯哲学的批判建构

邹丽   

  • 出版日期:2026-09-15 发布日期:2026-09-24
  • 作者简介:邹丽南开大学商学院信息资源管理系,博士研究生。研究方向:图书馆信息学基础理论、图书馆学史、信息社会问题等。Email: zouli@mail.nankai.edu.cn天津300071

Wiegands Reflections on Theoretical Approaches to the Library Profession in the United States: A Critical Construction Based on Foucaults Philosophy

Zou Li   

  • Online:2026-09-15 Published:2026-09-24
  • About author:Zou Li

摘要: 威甘德作为享誉世界的批判反思型图书馆史学家,以其独特的理论视角重构了美国公共图书馆及其职业体系的历史叙事。本文通过系统梳理其代表性著述,在对核心文本进行精细解读的基础上,提炼出威甘德反思美国图书馆职业的关键论述,并将其思想与福柯“知识—权力—话语”理论体系进行比对分析。研究发现,威甘德的批判实践深受福柯哲学的启发,其反思聚焦于公共图书馆及其职业体系作为权力与话语隐性运作的制度化场域,系统揭示了该场域所承载的文化规训与社会再生产功能。这一批判路径不仅动摇了关于图书馆民主角色与职业中立性的传统认知,也呈现出哲学理论在图书馆史研究领域的解释力与理论生产力。威甘德的研究不仅对美国图书馆学界产生了深远影响,还为世界其他国家和地区的图书馆事业发展及理论研究提供了重要启示。对我国图书馆界而言,威甘德的研究不仅可以激发学科主体的反思性自觉,还能够展示如何将哲学理论的洞察力转化为学科反思力。当下我国图书馆学正积极推进中国自主知识体系的战略构建,在这样的背景下,运用哲学批判的实践功能,保持对图书馆制度、技术和话语权力的反思,或许有助于强化图书馆学科自主知识体系的理论根基。

关键词: 威甘德, 福柯, 美国公共图书馆, 职业中立性, 反思批判

Abstract: As a worldrenowned critical and reflective historian of librarianship, Wayne A. Wiegand has reconstructed the historical narrative of American public libraries and their professional systems through his unique theoretical perspective. This paper systematically reviews his representative works, conducts a detailed analysis of core texts, and distills Wiegands key arguments on the American library profession. It then compares and analyzes his ideas with Michel Foucaults “knowledgepowerdiscourse” theoretical framework. The study finds that Wiegands critical practice was deeply influenced by Foucaults philosophy. His reflections focused on public libraries and their professional systems as institutionalized domains where power and discourse operated implicitly. He systematically revealed the cultural disciplining and social reproduction functions embedded within these domains. This critical approach not only challenges conventional understandings of the democratic role and professional neutrality of libraries but also demonstrates the explanatory power and theoretical productivity of philosophical theory in the field of library history research. Wiegands research has had a profound impact on the American library community and provides important insights for the development of library services and theoretical research in other countries and regions around the world. For Chinas library community, Wiegands research not only stimulates reflective selfawareness among disciplinary actors but also demonstrates how philosophical insights can be transformed into disciplinary reflective capacity. As Chinas library science advances towards the strategic goal of constructing an autonomous knowledge system, employing the practical functions of philosophical criticism to maintain reflection on institutional structures, technologies, and discursive power may help strengthen the theoretical foundations of an autonomous knowledge system for the discipline.

Key words: Wayne A. Wiegand, Michel Foucault, American public library, Professional neutrality, Critical reflection