图书馆杂志

图书馆杂志 ›› 2023, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (382): 36-43.

• 理论探索 • 上一篇    下一篇

司法场域中《公共图书馆法》表达与实践(2018-2021)——以法院165份裁判文书为研究样本

张 健 张东禹(江苏大学法学院)   

  • 出版日期:2023-02-15 发布日期:2023-03-02
  • 作者简介:张 健 江苏大学法学院,副教授,硕士研究生导师。研究方向:诉讼法。作者贡献:论文选题、写作与修改。E-mail:honglou2011@163.com 江苏镇江 212013 张东禹 江苏大学法学院,硕士研究生。研究方向:法理学。作者贡献:论文写作与材料整理。江苏镇江 212013

Empirical Study on Judicial Application of Public Library Law(2018-2021): A Sample of 165 Court Decisions

Zhang Jian, Zhang Dongyu (School of Law, Jiangsu University)   

  • Online:2023-02-15 Published:2023-03-02
  • About author:Zhang Jian, Zhang Dongyu (School of Law, Jiangsu University)

摘要:

《公共图书馆法》司法适用是检验该法立法效果的重要标准,也为推动该法的未来完善提供了观察的窗口。《公共图书馆法》自2018 年颁布至今,在司法实践中发挥了一定的作用。对该法颁布实施后的三年来的165 份裁判文书统计分析发现,《公共图书馆法》司法适用呈现案件逐年递增、区域分布不均、法院层级下移等特点。司法实践中,《公共图书馆法》发挥了权利主张、价值宣示与规范强制等功能。不过,该法存在宣示性条款较多、直接约束力较弱以及司法适用频率较低等问题。未来,需提高《公共图书馆法》立法质量、完善法院裁判文书说理内容、加大普法力度,更好地促进我国公共图书馆事业进一步发展。

Abstract: The judicial application of the Public Library Law is an important standard to test thelegislative effect of the law, and also provides a window of observation for promoting the futureimprovement of the law. Since its promulgation in 2018, the Public Library Law has played a significantrole in judicial practice. Through the statistical analysis of 165 judgment documents in the past three yearsafter the promulgation and implementation of the law, it is found that the judicial application of the PublicLibrary Law shows the characteristics of increasing cases year by year, uneven regional distribution anddownward shift in court level. In judicial practice, the Public Library Law claims the rights, declares thevalue, and enforces standardization. However, the law has many problems, such as excessive declarativeprovisions, weak direct binding force and low frequency of judicial application. In the future, it isnecessary to improve the legislative quality of the Public Library Law, perfect the reasoning componentof court judgment documents, and strengthen the popularization of law, so as to better promote the furtherdevelopment of China’s public library cause.