Libraly Journal

Libraly Journal ›› 2026, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (10): 36-44.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

The Legitimacy Dilemma of Controlled Digital Lending in Libraries and Its Solutions

Li Qiang, Lin Shufeng, Yu Yuan   

  • Online:2026-10-15 Published:2026-10-27
  • About author:Li Qiang, Lin Shufeng, Yu Yuan

Abstract: Controlled Digital Lending(CDL) has received a lot of attention both domestically and internationally as a beneficial practice for libraries to adapt to the transformation and upgrade their services in the digital age. The introduction of CDL in China needs to address its legitimacy under Copyright Law. On the basis of reviewing relevant research at home and abroad, this paper clarifies the corresponding approach to amending the CDL by examining the complex relationship between the copyright exhaustion doctrine and fair use, as well as the institutional barriers posed by current laws. To resolve the legality dilemma of CDL, the long-term consideration is to establish a digital copyright exhaustion doctrine. At present, CDL could instead be recognized under copyright law as a form of fair use. Guided by the principle of balancing interests, existing institutional barriers should be overcome by constructing a legal regulatory mechanism extending from general law to special law and from principle provisions to specific provisions. The paper also proposes specific provisions concerning the fair use of CDL for inclusion in relevant laws and regulations.