图书馆杂志

图书馆杂志 ›› 2025, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (417): 132-139.

• 文献考论 • 上一篇    下一篇

上海图书馆藏《钱塘遗事》四库底本的文献价值

唐 宸   

  • 出版日期:2026-01-15 发布日期:2026-01-29
  • 作者简介:

    唐 宸 清华大学人文学院,副教授。研究方向:版本目录学、数字人文、三礼经学等。E-mail tangchen @mail. tsinghua. edu. cn 北京 100084

A Study on the Siku‘s Master Copy of Qiantang Yi Shi Collected in Shanghai Library

Tang Chen   

  • Online:2026-01-15 Published:2026-01-29
  • About author:Tang Chen

摘要:

元人刘一清《钱塘遗事》的汪启淑家藏抄本是乾隆三十八年四月因纂修《四库全书》而重出江湖的一部孤本文献,次年四月获乾隆帝手书题诗,发还本家,随后长期下落不明。此书现今通行各版本皆源出四库阁本,已经过馆臣的全面校勘与肆意篡改。上海图书馆藏有此书抄本一部,有乾隆帝手书题诗、满汉文翰林院印和馆臣校改校签,应即汪氏藏本实物,可与其他汪氏四库进呈本相参证。上图抄本在复原该书版本原貌、反映四库馆臣擅改痕迹和校勘水平等方面具有重要的文献价值。乾隆帝通过两次题诗亲自参与该书作者考证,并借以强化其批判钱谦益等贰臣“ 进退无据” 的政治主张,更是《四库全书》阅读史上一个特殊而生动的案例。

Abstract:

The long lost handwritten copy of Qiantang Yi Shi is Liu Yiqing’s work and published in theYuan dynasty. It‘s transcript is a unique copy which was collected by Wang Qishu resurfaced in 1773due to the compilation of the Siku Quanshu. The following year this copy was inscribed with a poem inthe hand of Emperor Qianlong and was returned to the Wang Qishu. Afterward it remained missing for along time. The current circulating editions of Qiantang Yi Shi all originate from the Siku Quanshu whichhas been collated and arbitrarily altered by the imperial librarians namely some people who compiled SikuQuanshu. Shanghai Library possesses a copy of this book which features a poem written by EmperorQianlong on the front matter bearing the Imperial Academy seal in both Manchu and Chinese charactersand containing traces of corrections made by the imperial librarians. This copy which collected inShanghai Library is the very same edition that was originally in the collection of Wang Qishu and can becross-referenced with other book submissions made by the Wang family to the imperial court. Consequentlythis copy is of great importance in reconstructing the original appearance of the book’s edition as well asin reflecting the traces of alterations and the level of collation expertise exhibited by the imperiallibrarians. Emperor Qianlong personally participated in the research of the author of the book throughinscribing two poems thereby reinforcing his political stance of criticizing turncoat officials like QianQianyi for their equally difficult to go on or retreat . This is a unique and vivid case in the readinghistory of the Siku Quanshu.

Key words: Qiantang Yi Shi Siku, Master Copy, Wang Qishu, Shanghai Library, Documentary value